At certain, albeit fleeting, moments in one's life
the meaning of music dawns upon you. I'd like to tell
you about one of the biggest moments of musical
understanding I was lucky enough to experience, but
unfortunately I have far too little faith in the
English language.
Believe me, I wish I could explain exactly what I
came to understand at that particular moment, why it
moved me until I was choking back tears, and the
vision I had for music and mankind. But like a wily
little leprechaun it was all gone in a flash. So
instead of flailing around in transcendental
superlatives and wishy-washy emotional verbalization
I'd like to approach my experience from the other side
of my brain. Thanks to a recording I have had ample
time to review it from a purely audio-factual
perspective -- what exactly my ears were hearing at
each moment. I learned a lot through my scrutiny, from
ideas as absolute as guitar techniques to concepts as
heady as what really constitutes dynamic intensity in
improvisation. I'd even call it an intellectual and
spiritual journey, from my understanding the exact
moment it was over until right now as I'm writing
this. I'd like to take you on a highly abridged
version of this journey. For lack of a less cumbersome
moniker I'll call it the "Voyage of the Last Ten
Minutes of Hampton '97 Halley's Comet".
If you get a free moment with a piano, try doing
this. Play a bunch of C's while holding down the
sustain pedal so you get a big wash of the pitch.
Then, somewhere high up, tap just one F#. If it sounds
wrong or unsettling then you're hearing it like a true
westerner should. For centuries western tonality
regarded that interval as the most dissonant, the
tritone. Monks were banished for even thinking of
composing with it, classical composers claimed it
demanded resolution and set it up as the antithesis to
the goal of the I chord. Fortunately our modern ears
are capable of hearing it in a number of other
contexts. One of the most beautiful is in the shape of
lydian modality. While the term sounds brainy to the
layman, the Lydian mode couldn't be simpler. Just take
a C major scale and replace F with F#, raising the
fourth step of the scale a half-step. This is the
fourth mode of the major scale, and when you sit on it
most people describe it as sounding "dream-like". The
most dissonant, or "dreamy", of the notes is clearly
the F#, and for some the sound of it really takes some
getting used to. Yet when your ears start to feel
comfortable with the Lydian mode you can kind of just
float along with it, aimlessly, without any desire for
movement. I even go so far as to say it sounds
heavenly or unearthly, as if it were the mode most
closely related to God.
At 16:18 Mike decides it's time to take us there.
Up to that point the band had been engaging in some
ruthlessly dark funk for about 9 minutes. Trey and
Page had engaged in lots of interplay, phrase trading
and the like. The groove had been very constant, Fish
hadn't moved from the same ride/bass/snare pulses at
all and his fills were minimal. As with much of
Phish's minor funk improvisation the jam to this point
explored the dorian mode, in this case G dorian. The
notable difference between a jam in a dorian mode as
opposed to regular minor is the raised sixth step of
the scale. The difference present in dorian gives the
jam a little naughtier flavor and is quite typical,
even taken for granted. Yet at 16:18 when Mike is
inspired to change the root of the jam form G to Bb,
it has profound consequences.
Suddenly the jam has a new tonal home base, Bb. This
note gets juxtaposed against G dorian, that is Page
and Trey continue to play all the agreed upon notes
from the first nine minutes but they are now heard in
the context of Mike's new tonal center. Within
seconds, whether they know it or not, everyone not
unconscious in the Hampton Coliseum is hearing Bb
Lydian loud and clear. Page and Trey take heed and it
breathes new life into the jam.
For about a minute previous to Mike's transposition
Trey had been opening his wah the farthest on the
fourth beat of every second measure. This provided the
rhythmic motif that Mike decides to use for his Bb - a
stark, single Bb on the fourth beat of every second
measure. Soon Trey and Fish follow suit. At 16:30 Trey
is hammering big wahed-out Bb's on that beat. Fish has
abandoned the kick and snare and resigned himself to
cymbal crashes on the accented beat with eight notes
on the ride to keep the pulse. By 17:00, with one
single note less than a minute earlier, Mike has
changed the tonality of the jam from mean funk to
light serenity, as well as changed the pulse from
steadily driving funk to timed bursts of sound.
This general idea continues as the band gets
progressively softer with each accented hit, and all
the while Page's clavi chords texturize Bb Lydian. By
18:00 the band has gotten really quiet, and Trey has
looped his Bb feedback for a quiet drone. The band is
a good three or four dynamic markings quieter than
they were a minute ago. Just as the music reaches a
virtual whisper the crowd goes bonkers. Yet that's
just where the clinic begins.
All the material from the last two minutes of the
jam, the Bb Lydian tonality, the accent on the eighth
beat, the Bb drone, can be viewed as a foreword to the
jam's final statement, which I consider to last from
about the twenty minute mark forward. It becomes one
of the most cohesive climaxes to a jam I've ever
heard, and how they go about doing it is where most of
the beauty and knowledge of our journey can be found.
I constantly hear fans of improvisational bands talk
about a jam's "peak"; oftentimes the dynamic summit is
the most noticed and easily discernable facet of an
improvisation. Certainly critical listeners and
performers alike have more developed notions of what
constitutes a "peak" than mere volume. In fact a more
applicable definition of a "peak" is really the
accomplishment of a musical goal, where the musician
sets out to morph a facet of his playing towards a
polar opposite. This can be as simple as increasing a
guitar volume from clean picking to searing
distortion, to as developed as working a melody around
a harmonic cycle towards a desired key. At 20:00 each
member of the band picks a desired transformation of
their playing and gradually carries it out,
simultaneously, until 22:50, at which point the band
reaches a peak. I'd like to spell out each players
transformation so you can see the unique facet that
they use to peak and why it's so effective, innovative
and inspirational.
Trey's transformation is found within the rapidity and
phrasing of his soloing. He is constantly soloing
within Bb Lydian, playing melodic, non-repetitive
phrases to ornament the section. At 20:00 he starts
his soloing with sparse phrases that begin and end
about once every eight beats. At this point the
phrases also follow the pulse precisely, making sure
each note falls of an exact beat. His solo phrases get
longer and longer and gradually stray from the pulse.
At 20:41 he plays a line that soars beyond the beat,
seemingly floating on an arbitrary tempo unrelated to
the jam. By 22:10 he is absolutely shredding; his
alternate-picked lines are a constant stream of notes
that carry on for more than four measures at a time.
By 22:50 (the peak) Trey is doing his Joe Satriani
impersonation, playing huge wah covered lydian runs as
fast as his fingers can handle.
The motivic transformation found in Page's
playing is more easily heard. He uses his Moog to
create big sweeping glissandos (pitch bends) that
start in the lower register at 19:50 and work their
way up to a screaming height at 22:50. At each moment
he is bending one to three pitches, and they move in
various directions to various intervals. At 22:21 this
independence of each pitch bend is heard, as four
pitches unfold to form an Am7 chord. Within the three
minute climb towards the peak these pitches climb
across four octaves. At the peak Page is bending up to
the same pitch summit over and over again, seemingly
reinforcing the arrival at the finish line.
The rhythm section peaks in two opposite
directions. Just before 19:00 Fish introduces a new
groove, a half-time take on the previous beat. At the
onset he is merely providing a simple pulse, his
motivic transition soon comes in his filling. At 19:45
the first tom-tom fills begin on the second half of
each second measure. One minute later the fills are
longer and arrive more arbitrarily. At 22:50 Fish's
drum set is quaking, as he bashes out a continuous
crash-cymbal and bass-drum roll for about four
measures. Mike does quite the opposite. His bass lines
at 19:45 is lightly bouncing, accenting the #4, fifth
and root. By the peak he has abandoned all
ornamentation for a low Bb, his transition from melody
to a drone that swells like an anchor against the
rapidity of the guitar and drums.
And at 22:50, I guess, that's where I had my
moment of understanding. Amidst Trey's ripping, Page's
screaming, Fish's wall of drums, Mike's root and
Hampton's ovation I was moved to that higher plane of
consciousness. The peak just snuck up on me, honestly.
The melodic transposition, the pulse trading, the
looped drones had me hooked. By the time the peak came
I hadn't realized we were headed towards it, and the
surprise, compounded with the musical embodiment of
seeing Halley's Comet, worked me.
When one micro-examines each little aspect
there is tons to be learned; when one studies the big
picture its even more of a workshop. This piece could
be analyzed far more in depth and it would prove to be
just as rich. The outro jam, from 23:05-24:30, has a
great deal more of worth while stuff to look at, in
particularly a fresh little drum theme. I'll let you
have a listen, and see if you can carry this journey
onward.
Jordan Crisman is a bass player known for his work with the band
Cantus as well as his brief stint with the Disco Biscuits during
Marc Brownstein's hiatus. Crisman examined
the Slip song "Hey Worrier" in the February issue of jambands.com.