The Disco Biscuits returned to the stage for the first time since September last night to play a sold out show at New York’s Best Buy Theater. The band’s first set included two songs the band has not played in 2011—“Resurrection” and “You and I”—as well as the old school favorites “Plan B,” “Aceetobee” and “Mr. Don.” The band’s second set was a near seamless performance, consisting of “Spraypaint” and a segue from “Shelby Rose” into an inverted “Crickets,” “The Great Abyss,” the first part of “Crickets” and “Shelby Rose.” The lone encore of “I Remember When” ended the show. The Disco Biscuits will return to the Best Buy tonight.

Here’s a look at last night’s setlist via Phantasy Tour

Set 1: Resurrection > Plan B > Aceetobee (1) > You and I, Mr. Don

Set 2: Spraypaint, Shelby Rose > Crickets (2) > The Great Abyss > Crickets (3) > Shelby Rose

Encore: I Remember When

(3) inverted (ending/beginning)
(2) inverted (middle section)
(1) unfinished