Last night, My Morning Jacket continued to make good on Jim James’ promise to not repeat any songs during their current four-night run at New York’s Beacon Theatre, as the band kept the rarities and bustouts coming.

During the 23-song performance, James and crew touched on various points in his and the Jacket’s careers, including two tunes from James’ side-projects, “Quick Like a Flash” from The New Basement Tapes project and the Monsters of Folk song “The Right Place.”

Some songs had their first appearance in a while, beginning with the opener “Butch Cassidy,” which hadn’t been played since July 2013. “Librarian” saw it’s first inclusion since that same month, followed by the first “Look At You” since September 2012. The biggest bustout of the night came with “If All Else Fails,” a Tennesee Fire track that hadn’t been played since November 2011.

After the main set, which also featured newer songs like “Get the Point,” “Spring (Among the Living),” “Big Decisions” and “Only Memories Remain,” all from the band’s most recent effort, The Waterfall, the four-song encore kicked off with the recently brought back “Remnants” and “Highly Suspicious,” which can be viewed above. Consult the full setlist below.

My Morning Jacket
Beacon Theatre, New York, NY

Butch Cassidy, Get the Point, Librarian, Look at You, Rollin Back, Heartbreakin Man, It Beast 4 U, Spring (Among the Living), How Do You Know, Big Decisions, The Day is Coming, Quick Like a Flash, If All Else Fails, Like A River, The Right Place, Lowdown, Only Memories Remain, Honest Man, It’s About Twilight Now

Enc: Remnants, Highly Suspicious, Lay Low, I’m Amazed

Source: setlist.fm