According to TMZ, My Morning Jacket is being sued for allegedly disfiguring a man in a car accident in 2013.

Margarito Gonzalez alleges in his lawsuit that frontman Jim James was behind the wheel of a car with two other members of the band in Denver when the two collided. In the suit, Gonzalez alleges James was driving recklessly and following too closely.

Pitchfork reports that a lawyer for Jim James filed paperwork to move the case to a federal court in Colorado and according to those records, Gonzalez filed a lawsuit against James and My Morning Jacket Tours, Inc.