Phish and Madison Square Garden celebrated the end of the band’s historic thirteen-night run with a banner commemorating the event, placed in the rafters next to Billy Joel’s previous accomplishment. Business Insider reports that the venue plans to leave the banner up in its famed rafters, with a caveat.

Phish wrapped up their run on Sunday night with the thirteenth show held on what will now be known as “Phish Day” thanks to a proclamation by New York Mayor Bill de Blasio.

The band returns to the stage over Labor Day Weekend at Dick’s Sporting Goods Park.